As a parent of an advancing student musician, there comes a turning point in their musical journey when their beginner instrument simply can’t keep up with their talent. Their middle school or high school band director has dropped the hint: It is time for an upgrade. When you start browsing the market for intermediate and professional clarinets, oboes, or bassoons, you will immediately notice a massive fork in the road regarding materials: Plastic (Resonite/ABS Resin) vs. Wooden (Grenadilla Wood) instruments. An upgrade is a significant financial investment for any family. To help you make the most informed decision for your child’s development and your family's budget, this guide breaks down the core structural, tonal, and maintenance differences between plastic and wooden woodwind instruments.
Plastic Instruments: Durable, Reliable, and Worry-Free
Most beginner student instruments are constructed from high-grade ABS plastic or resin (often marketed under names like Resonite).
The Pros:
-
Extreme Durability: Plastic instruments are virtually indestructible. They are entirely immune to changes in weather, temperature, and humidity. This makes them the absolute best choice for marching band woodwind sections or students who travel frequently.
-
Low Maintenance: A plastic clarinet or oboe will never crack. If your child accidentally leaves it in a cold school locker or a hot car overnight, the material will not suffer structural damage.
-
Affordability: Plastic instruments are significantly cheaper to manufacture, keeping the retail price down and saving room in your budget for essential everyday instrument accessories.
The Cons:
-
Tonal Limitations: While modern resin manufacturing is incredibly advanced, plastic lacks the acoustic depth, warmth, and complex resonance of natural wood. As a student advances into solo competitions and collegiate auditions, a plastic instrument can sound bright or brittle in the upper registers.
🪵 Wooden Instruments: Premium Tone, Rich Resonance
Professional and high-level intermediate woodwinds are crafted from dense, premium hardwoods—most commonly Grenadilla wood (African Blackwood).
The Pros:
-
Unmatched Sound Quality: Wood is a living, breathing material. Its natural grain creates a dark, rich, and warm acoustic core. It provides the complex overtones and flexible intonation required for concert bands, symphony orchestras, and solo festival performances.
-
Resale Value: A well-maintained wooden instrument holds its value incredibly well. If your child pursues music in college or later decides to sell the horn, a premium wooden instrument remains a highly sought-after commodity.
The Cons:
-
High Maintenance and Sensitivity: Wood expands and contracts when exposed to moisture and temperature changes. If a wooden instrument dries out too quickly or gets exposed to a sudden cold draft, the body can literally split open, resulting in catastrophic cracks that require expensive professional repairs.
-
Price Point: Premium materials and precise hand-craftsmanship mean wooden instruments come with a premium price tag.
⚖️ The Verdict: Which Material is Right for Your Child?
Choose Plastic If:
Your child is a middle schooler, participates heavily in outdoor marching band, or tends to be a bit careless with their gear. A high-quality resin instrument will survive the elements and classroom bumps while providing a highly dependable response.
Choose Wood If:
Your child is a dedicated high school or college-bound musician who primarily plays in indoor concert ensembles, auditions for All-State groups, and has demonstrated the maturity needed to handle a strict daily woodwind maintenance routine.
The Golden Rules of Wooden Instrument Care
If you do decide to take the leap and purchase a wooden instrument, your child must upgrade their care habits. Make sure their case is always stocked with these protective supplies from Reeds for Less:
-
A Microfiber Pull-Through Swab: Moisture must be removed immediately after every playing session using a weighted microfiber clarinet swab to prevent water from soaking into the grain.
-
Two-Way Humidity Packets: Keep a humidity control pack (like Boveda) inside the case shell to maintain a stable environment and prevent the wood from drying out and cracking during winter.
-
Premium Cork Grease: Wooden joints fit tightly. Applying a thin layer of cork grease ensures the instrument assembles smoothly without placing bending pressure on the fragile wooden tenons.
Find Your Upgrade Accessories at Reeds for Less
No matter which material fits your child's current musical level, Reeds for Less is here to support their growth. From student-friendly bulk items to professional performance gear, we supply families and school programs with authentic, top-tier accessories at prices that make sense.